To the extent that clustered heatmaps are your thing, and I've seen an increasing array in the literature over time, some Stata coding suggestions are here. A few examples from the discussion follow.
Bringing Data and Methods to Our Legal Madness (v.2.0)
To the extent that clustered heatmaps are your thing, and I've seen an increasing array in the literature over time, some Stata coding suggestions are here. A few examples from the discussion follow.
Insofar as a lot of empirical legal analyses involve logit estimations (or some version of logit: e.g., probit, melogit, xtlogit, zoilogit, etc.), I thought a recent discussion/summary of related post-estimation options on StataList might interest some folks (click here). Unsurprisingly, margins dominates the discussion (as well as the note that the margins command requires factor variables).
As a fan of Edward Tufte and his classic, The Visual Display of Quantitative Information (1983), since grad school, I wanted to pass along the following statistical chart gems (drawn from here).
In the wake of the "#MeToo" movement, in 2018 California lawmakers enacted the Stand Together Against Non-Disclosure (STAND) Act, which sets out to promote greater transparency in the resolution of sex discrimination, harassment, and abuse cases. At the same time, the STAND Act also helps frame analyses of questions relating to "what exactly happens in the wake of [such a] reform."
In another installment from their on-going exploration of "secret settlements," David Freeman Engstrom (Stanford) et al., assess a quarter-million case filings from the Los Angeles County Superior Court for insights on how the STAND Act may have influenced litigation patterns.
Core claims reported in Shedding Light on Secret Settlements: An Empirical Study of California’s STAND Act include what the study did not find. Notably, "the STAND Act did not yield a sharp increase or decrease in case filings. Nor did the Act appear to significantly prolong cases or amplify their intensity." That is to say, the paper argues that evidence from the STAND Act implies that parties will still settle cases even without the inducement of secrecy. An excerpted abstract follows.
While problems with under-powered studies are well-understood, one under-appreciated aspect involves data noise. This subtle wrinkle is discussed in a recent (and helpful) post by Andrew Gelman (click here). Gelman's main point is that, when it comes to addressing under-powered studies, "the real problem is noise, not N."
Gelman's point is well-taken, if oft-ignored. For many researchers, the go-to remedy for under-powered studies is to simply increase sample size (N). Gelman's post underscores that "[n]oise (variation in effect size, variation in outcomes, and measurement error) is more of an issue than sample size because lots of bad studies are so noisy that, to get a large enough sample size to detect a reliable effect, you’d need N = a zillion, and at that point you’d be averaging over such a wide range of conditions that it’s not clear what you’re estimating anyway." Thus, possible solutions to problems attributable to under-powered studies benefit from multivariate rather than univariate approaches.
While Stata's graph commands can be notoriously complicated, some can be worth the effort. For example, adding CI shading to a conventional line graph permits researchers to move from this:
to something like this:
How to do so in Stata is discussed here.
Questions about whether justice is, indeed, blind, persist. One particular question, whether judges treat litigants differently based on ethnicity, continues to receive attention in the United States as well as Europe.
In a recent contribution to this literature, Do German Judges Treat People With Foreign Names Differently? A Vignette Experiment, the authors, Alexander Morell (Goethe Univ.-Frankfurt) and Aileen Oeberst (Indep.), report experimental findings drawn from 282 sitting German judges designed to assess whether "German judges evaluate a case differently when the defendant bears a Turkish rather than a German name." To do so, the authors executed a preregistered vignette experiment in a 2 × 2 between-subject design featuring two experimental factors: the defendant’s name (Turkish versus German) and the consistency of the witness testimony.
While the study’s main results reassure as they “show little evidence of average differential treatment by defendant name across most outcomes,” one of the study’s robustness checks finds “an interaction between the consistency of the evidence and the effect of a Turkish name." An excerpted abstract follows.
It is with a heavy heart that I note the passing of Prof. Tom Ulen, a leading empirical (and theoretical) law and economics scholar. Along with his seminal scholarly contributions, Tom will also be remembered for his kindness, warmth, mentorship, and humor. Tom is already deeply missed by many. (Click here for a memorial notice from the European Association of Law and Economics.)
Registration
Registration is now open for the 2026 Conference on Empirical Legal Studies (CELS), which will take place on October 2-3, 2026, at Northwestern Pritzker School of Law in Chicago. Registration, hotel information, travel grant information, and more are available on the conference website: https://cels2026.com.
We encourage participants to register and reserve hotel accommodations as soon as possible.
Hotel Information
We have reserved a block of rooms at The Wade hotel near Northwestern Law at a conference rate of $189 per night. The conference block is available for October 1-2, 2026, and the deadline to reserve a room at The Wade Hotel at the CELS 2026 group rate is Friday, September 11, 2026.
Book at The Wade at the CELS 2026 group rate.
If you would like to arrive earlier or depart later, please contact the hotel directly: